The Story Your Brand Is Accidentally Telling

filed in brand writing - jan 2026

Your brand is already telling a story. The question is whether it's the one you meant to tell.

This is something I think about a lot, and something I see constantly in the brands I work with. Not bad brands...actually, usually quite good ones. Built by smart, capable people who have been so focused on doing the work that they haven't stopped to notice what their presence is quietly communicating to everyone watching.

Meaning, when your website copy sounds like it was written for everyone, the story it tells is: "We're not sure who we're for." It's the brand equivalent of showing up to a party and trying to make friends with every single person in the room. It reads as uncertain, even when the business behind it is anything but.

When your About page leads with your credentials instead of your conviction, the story it tells is: "We'd like you to be impressed, not moved." Credentials matter. But they're not what make someone lean in. What makes someone lean in is understanding why you do what you do - the belief underneath the resume.

When your visuals are inconsistent (some polished, some rushed, some borrowed from a trend that felt right six months ago) the story it tells is: "We're figuring it out as we go." Even if you're not. Even if behind the scenes you are running the tightest, most intentional operation. Inconsistency creates doubt where there shouldn't be any.
None of these are fatal. All of them are fixable.

But first you have to see the story you're accidentally telling. That requires a little distance from your own brand, which is genuinely hard to have when you're inside it every day. It's one of the reasons I do what I do, because sometimes it takes a fresh set of eyes and the right questions to surface what's actually being communicated versus what you intended.

The brands that earn real loyalty, the ones people recommend without being asked, are the ones where every touchpoint tells the same story. On purpose.

If you're not sure what story your brand is telling right now, that's exactly where we start!

share:

Comments +

Comments will show here
Comment Form will show here.
Contact

Journey Storytelling.

Batch a month's worth of content in 60 minutes

Free download

The Storyteller's Guide to Social Media

download now

Hurray!

Click below to access your free download

Download the pdf